OMG that mockup video is so great, I am watching it on loop.
to me, stacks are a specific type of group because it the cards are strictly serial. but it feels like this covers a lot of use cases for groups. you do lose spatial relationships, but that might be a more rare use case. I don’t see why you would need to lose connections.
I love this concept. it accomplishes a lot: it lets you tightly organize cards, prevents them from overlapping, makes it easy to manipulate the group. you could style the upmost card in some conventional way to communicate a group title.
I’m going back and forth on this. I observed how I was creating small groups of cards in my various spaces. I now think this is quite common (taking back what I said about “more rare use case”), and I wouldn’t want to use this stack grouping for those uses.
I still think the concept is super dope and I would probably grow into finding ways to use it, but the beauty of Kinopio is how easy it is to rearrange cards. I often will make a list, but then soon thereafter pull one of those items somewhere else or move it to be next to another card, etc. in these cases, I would find a fairly “tight” stack limiting and tend not to use it.
Nested cards (one parent with multiple children) is a must. Having connector points for each (parent and children) will be cool too. @pirijan, your mock-up above is good enough. Any clues as to when this can be released?
i’m just here to add my vote for a grouping feature as briefly discussed on Discord.
I was thinking something “UI easy”, like how photo editing and wireframe software like Balsamiq (my role model for well impleneted grouping) do it.
Just “CTRL-G” to group and “CTRL-SHIFT-G” to ungroup, or an extra button “Group / Ungroup” in the context menu when selecting.
Basically the “minimum viable grouping”
To me, a group “just” needs to behave like a selection of multiple cards, i.e. when you move them, they keep their relative position to one another.
I wouldn’t even need a visual indicator. It’s OK to find out a card belongs to a group just by moving it.
To me it’s the one feature that would make me upgrade.
At the moment I super love Kinopio to quickly get my thoughts out and scribble a quick first version. But I find myself using something else for the real planning and work. It’s just to easy to pull a card out of context by mistake.
Apart from that, please keep it up, I’m happy to have found Kinopio!
should you only be able to have one group per space or multiple?
more than one, please
what happens if the same card belongs to multiple groups? (what happens if i drag it, do both groups move?)
a card would only belong to one group imho
if you select one/some of the cards in a group and hit ctrl-shift-g to ungroup does it remove the whole group, or just modifies the group to remove the selected cards from the group?
removing the whole group would be fine for me, but no strong opinion, whatever is easier to implement
Same with adding to a group, whatever is easier. I can imagine merging new cards into an existing group but also wouldn’t mind to first having to “ungroup” and then create a group from a new selection.
Very cool, looking forward if and what you come up with